Bollywood’s glamorous casting culture is facing harsh scrutiny following revelations from actors Isha Talwar and Bijou Thaangjam, who shared troubling experiences involving Yash Raj Films’ (YRF) top casting director Shanoo Sharma. Talwar, known for her roles in Mirzapur and Article 370, and Thaangjam, recognized for Mary Kom and Axone, have openly criticized what they describe as humiliating public audition methods that expose actors to unnecessary emotional strain.

Isha Talwar’s Shocking Revelation: Crying on Cue in a Restaurant

Isha Talwar stunned the Bollywood fraternity by revealing that she was once instructed by Shanoo Sharma to perform a crying scene in the middle of a busy Versova restaurant during an audition. This public display, Sharma insisted, was a test of Talwar’s ability to perform without inhibitions—even as diners ate at tables nearby. Talwar described the experience as confusing, humiliating, and confidence-shattering, emphasizing that it was a moment of public humiliation disguised as talent evaluation.

Talwar refused to give in to the demand to cry publicly, ultimately losing the role but proudly standing by her decision not to compromise her dignity. She also called for professional and respectful audition environments, suggesting that if such ‘real-location’ auditions were necessary, studios should hire appropriate venues and bear the costs, rather than subject actors to makeshift public tests.

Bijou Thaangjam Backs Talwar: Casting Circus and Cheap Stunts

Soon after Talwar’s account surfaced, Bijou Thaangjam lent support by sharing his own uncomfortable audition experience with Sharma, describing similar public and demeaning casting ‘stunts’ designed to belittle rather than assess genuine talent. Thaangjam called out such practices as “cheap stunts” and expressed frustration: “We’re actors, not puppets in your café drama.”

His story resonated with many, highlighting how these casting sessions often resemble showcases of power dynamics rather than respectful auditions. Thaangjam’s willingness to speak out adds weight to Talwar’s claims, positioning this controversy as more than isolated incidents but part of a problematic industry culture.

Widespread Criticism and Social Media Backlash

The revelations ignited a wave of criticism online, with users condemning Sharma’s conduct and the audition format. Comments described the scenario as “full of herself” and “intoxicated by gatekeeping power,” questioning why auditions must take place in public environments where actors risk embarrassment.

Memes and sarcastic remarks flooded social media, mocking the ordeal of being asked to cry amid restaurant noise and patrons. Many netizens empathized with Talwar and Thaangjam, underscoring how subjecting actors to coerced emotional displays publicly is less about talent evaluation and more about exercising control and dominance.

The Bigger Picture: Casting Culture and Gatekeeping in Bollywood

Shanoo Sharma is no minor figure; she is one of Bollywood’s most influential casting directors, credited with discovering stars like Ranveer Singh and launching major YRF films. However, Talwar and Thaangjam’s testimonies expose a disturbing gap between the glamorous façade of “star discovery” and the grueling, sometimes demeaning routines actors endure.

This controversy shines light on a long-standing issue where casting directors wield immense gatekeeping authority, and actors—especially newcomers—feel pressured to endure indignities for fear of blacklisting. The courage Talwar and Thaangjam show in speaking out may mark a pivotal moment, encouraging more industry professionals to question outdated audition practices and demand respect.

Towards Change: Will Bollywood Reform Its Audition Practices?

The public nature of these revelations, amplified by social media, has sparked widespread debate about professionalism and ethics in Bollywood auditions. If more actors join Talwar and Thaangjam in exposing similar experiences, it could force casting directors and studios to reconsider their processes.

Auditions held in controlled, private settings that respect actors’ dignity could become the norm, replacing the “coffee shop power trips” that actors have long silently endured. As Bollywood continues to evolve, this controversy could catalyze a healthier, more respectful casting culture—where talent is truly valued without emotional exploitation.

Read Also: Bollywood Unites to Pay Tribute at Prayer Meet for Sunder Singh Jolly

Get the latest Bollywood entertainment news, trending celebrity news, latest celebrity news, new movie reviews, latest entertainment news, latest Bollywood news, and Bollywood celebrity fashion & style updates!

HOW DID YOU LIKE THIS ARTICLE? CHOOSE YOUR EMOTICON!